Discussion in 'Fibromyalgia Main Forum' started by quanked, Nov 9, 2010.

  1. quanked

    quanked Member

    i thought that Canadian health care was different than this.

    The End of Universal Health Care in Canada?

    Canada is in the beginning stages of a health care crisis. The federal government in Ottawa, which is controlled by Prime Minister Steven Harper's Conservative Party, has indicated it plans to hold funding increases to the provinces' Medicare systems in line with inflation when the current funding accord expires in three years. This will be a disaster for the provinces, and quite possibly the end of the universal health care system that Canadians take for granted.

    Funding Formula Gap

    Currently, the federal government contributes about 20 cents of every dollar spent by the provinces. The provinces themselves come up with the rest of the funding. Until 2013-14, Ottawa is committed to a 6% increase in its contribution every fiscal year, but they plan to drop back to the rate of inflation at 0 – 2% when the current agreement expires.

    Given that health care costs are increasing at a rate of 5 – 7% every year, the provinces will have to make up the difference by raiding funding from other programs like education, or simply cutting available Medicare programs by reducing or eliminating services, adding user fees, or allowing more private health insurance companies to operate within their jurisdictions.

    False Utopia

    I emigrated from the Midwest United States to Western Canada nearly four years ago. Since then I am often reminded by the liberal American friends I left behind just how lucky I am to live in a country where health care is universal and free.

    But it's not that simple in the way that reality never is. While the Canadian Medicare system is in theory a single payer system with a level playing field in terms of accessibility, it's hardly free. And not many average Canadians would say it was the best system in terms of customer service, ease of use or even access.

    Never Recovered From Cuts in 1990's

    The 1990's saw huge cuts in nurses and hospital access in an effort to reduce and cap increasing costs, and most provinces have yet to recover from either.

    Staff shortages continue and most hospitals run at capacity, which means that anything short of a life-threatening emergency strands patients on waiting lists or lining the hallways of emergency rooms, waiting for a bed to open up.

    Worst of all, in the eyes of Canadian citizens, the budget slashing of the 90's left them with an embittered medical profession, which now considers patient service dead last on their list of priorities. Complaints about service are nearly always met with a rejoinder to "contact your local MP and let them know you think there should be more funding for hospitals, health care workers and doctors." Health care professionals in my province, Alberta, see patients as a tool for promoting their grievances more than charges in their care.

    Personal Experience

    While I have never seen a doctor bill – nor does anyone else in Alberta - prescription drugs are not free. Only those who have private prescription plans through employers escape the full brunt of the cost for medications. In addition, eye and dental care is not covered by Medicare for anyone over the age of five, and catastrophic illnesses, like cancer, still carry the frightening potential for financial devastation if a person doesn't have some sort of private health insurance in addition to Medicare.

    Would I trade the system here for what I had? I was a public employee back in the States. My healthcare plan was worthy of envy, but by no means typical of what most Americans have. So if I had to choose between what I personally had and what I have now, I would gladly take the insurance I had as a teacher with its easy access to doctors, hospitals and services. I never waited. I didn't queue up as they do here. I really didn't worry.

    But if I had to trade my Canadian Medicare for what passes as health insurance for most people in the United States, I would keep my Alberta Health.

    I am lucky enough to have a family doctor. Many Canadians do not have a personal physician due to the doctor shortage, but this is largely the fault of the Canadian Medical Association (CMA) and not Medicare. The CMA keeps the numbers of working doctors artificially low by controlling the number of applicants allowed into medical schools and by lobbying the provinces to make it difficult for foreign-trained physicians to obtain a license to practice here. This allows them to maximize their profits as billing the provincial systems by office visits and procedures pays them piecemeal essentially. Doctors in Canada have no interest in seeing the current system continue and some openly advocate for private health insurance because it is the best thing for them financially.

    I have prescription drug, eye and dental care through private insurance provided by my husband's employer, so it is a misnomer to say that private insurance for health care isn't available in Canada. So aside from the fact that medical services basically don't exist outside emergency rooms and a few medi-centres on weekends and holidays, my family and I have adequate coverage and care. However, the working poor in Canada face some of the same problems they do in the U.S., as they are often forced to utilize ER's for common complaints and can't afford medications, eye exams or glasses and basic dental care.

    What's Next for Canadian Medicare?

    The Federal government in Canada currently shows little interest in sitting down to renegotiate the funding accord with the increasingly frantic Provinces. The aging Baby Boomer population and the expense of chronically ill patients, who are living longer and in need of more services, is not a problem faced just in the United States, but Canadians are not quite ready to deal with the realities of setting limits and prioritizing, which is something they have in common with their American cousins.

  2. TigerLilea

    TigerLilea Active Member

    Quanked, this is just one person's personal opinion of the Canadian health care system. Our system might not be perfect, however, I don't have any complaints. It has served me and my family well over the years. You don't ever hear of Canadians having to file bankruptcy, or have fund raisers to pay for our medical care. Americans can't say the same thing.
  3. mijanou

    mijanou Member

    I have had good health care but waiting to see a specialist could take up to 3 months so unless you are moderately healthy then it's not a problem.

    I've heard horror stories from people waiting for hip replacement surgery.

    I have to wait six months to have a polyp removed!

    So yeah you will see a doctor but may die waiting for the appointment.
  4. TigerLilea

    TigerLilea Active Member

    Hi Mijanou - I'm in Metro Vancouver and my mom had hip replacement surgery last June 2009. Her wait time was 3 weeks.

    Usually if something is an emergency and your doctor is on the ball, then you get fast tracked. A lot depends on how much effort your GP puts into getting you in to see a specialist.